The Decline of the Number 10: Why Playmaking Roles Are Shifting

For most of football's modern history, the number 10 came with a job description. Find a small, slightly top-heavy midfielder, station him in the pocket behind the striker, and allow him to vanish for stretches of play provided the goals kept arriving. The template produced Paul Scholes at Manchester United, Zinedine Zidane at Juventus and Real Madrid, Steven Gerrard at Liverpool, and Frank Lampard at Chelsea and England.

What has changed is not the quality of the game but the location of responsibility. Creativity has not disappeared; it has been scattered across the pitch into wingers who cut inside, strikers who drop deep, and full-backs who advance into midfield. The nominal playmaker still exists, but the role has been broken into pieces and reassembled according to how the modern game is measured, pressed and paid for.

The Number 10 as a Fixed Position

The old job spec was remarkably consistent. The playmaker would receive on the half-turn, weight the ball towards the goal and release a runner into the channel, all while remaining close enough to the striker that one pass could break a line. David Beckham supplied the delivery, Rui Costa supplied the invention, Ronaldinho and Wesley Sneijder supplied the spectacle. Their managers tolerated the lack of defensive work because the attacking output covered it.

That tolerance has evaporated under pressing systems. A midfielder who stands still during the opponent's build-up becomes a structural weakness, and the compactness demanded by gegenpressing leaves no obvious parking space in the pocket. The most obvious adaptation was demotion rather than extinction: creative players were pushed deeper into the eight position, where they could still receive between lines but also cover ground, jump into tackles and recycle possession.

The consequence is that the role has migrated rather than vanished. The long-running football journalism that documents these shifts captures the nostalgia well, and repositories such as Rock O' Mayne's archive of football writing still hold the kind of long-form analysis that put numbers on the page. What reads as a tactical revolution today was once a personality cult around one player in one position.

When the Nine Runs, the Ten Disappears

The most durable replacement for the classic playmaker is the false nine, a centre-forward who spends his evening dropping into the hole the number 10 used to occupy while a midfielder runs beyond him. Frank Lampard was converted into a false nine by Mourinho at Chelsea, and the ploy worked because Lampard arrived late, understood the penalty area and could still finish. Olivier Giroud offered something similar in France, Thomas Müller did it in Germany, and Harry Kane has made the dropped striker an institutional habit at Bayern.

Erling Haaland pushed the idea furthest by combining a striker's finishing with a playmaker's distribution, dragging centre-backs towards himself and freeing the runners in behind. Jude Bellingham's role at Real Madrid works in the opposite direction: a midfielder whose starting position is wide but whose attacking lane is inside the box. The label matters less than the function. One striker creates space and the other occupies it, and both are doing a share of the old number 10's job.

Football now routinely fields two players doing number 10 work at once, particularly in 4-2-3-1 and 3-4-2-1 systems. What disappeared is not creativity but exclusivity. The playmaker's function used to be exceptional enough to justify a specialist; now it is a duty split across two or three players, which explains why pure specialists feel increasingly rare.

The Wide Playmaker Moves Inside

The other major relocation happened on the touchline. Instead of staying wide and delivering crosses, elite wingers cut into the half-space, receive between the full-back and centre-back, and combine with the striker in a two-versus-one overload. Mohamed Salah, Son Heung-min, Jack Grealish and others have made the wide position a creative platform rather than a delivery duty.

That shift also pushed full-backs forward, since somebody has to supply the width once the winger leaves it. The inverted full-back, who tucks into midfield to create a numerical advantage and then races back, became a signature of the system Ange Postecoglou popularised at Celtic before taking it to the Premier League. Mark Pulisic's own project has hosted Neville's piece on the evolution of the wide attacker, a useful reminder that the argument about what a winger owes the team has been running for decades.

Resulting systems look lopsided on paper, with an inverted full-back and an inside winger sharing one side, but they are designed to pull the opposition's shape apart. The traditional wide man still exists, and crossing is still valuable, yet the highest-value wide players now earn their keep by arriving in dangerous central positions. The touchline became a starting point rather than a destination.

What the Numbers Now Reveal

Scouting has responded by measuring creation directly. Expected assists, chances created, progressive passes and ball-carrying value in the final third sit alongside expected goals, and the industry's data teams increasingly rate a forward on total attacking output rather than goals alone. A false nine with modest goal numbers can now be valued properly, which would have been difficult when the only reliable numbers came from the scoreboard.

Fantasy football accelerated the change, because points systems reward goals and clean sheets rather than a midfielder's pass that started a move ending in someone else's finish. Leagues across Australia, including the A-League's own fantasy product and the AFL's SuperCoach and head-to-head formats, have trained fans to distrust creative players without goal returns. Even in the real game, the incentive is similar: a manager who plays a hesitant number 10 is asked, immediately and publicly, why the team is not scoring.

Economics followed tactics. A creative midfielder who cannot press can be replaced by two energetic eights who combine, or by a forward who works the ninety minutes. Clubs have quietly stopped paying a premium for the shirt number and started paying for aggregate production. The genuine number 10 survives, but usually as a luxury in a specific system rather than as a permanent fixture.

Lessons From the Australian Game

Australian football has always been a productive laboratory for tactical change. The A-League Men operates with small squads and quick turnover, and matches at AAMI Park in Melbourne regularly feature committed, high-energy pressing that leaves little room for a static playmaker to hide. Melbourne Victory and Melbourne City split the derby crowd with a noise level that rivals anything in England, and players learn quickly that imagination without intensity is a liability in that environment.

Postecoglou's story belongs here too. Raised in Melbourne's Greek community and shaped by his years at South Melbourne in the National Premier Leagues before the national stage, he took inverted full-backs and relentless width to Celtic and then to Tottenham and Liverpool. His Melbourne roots explain why Australian viewers treat his European success less as foreign news than as local vindication, and why tactical observers here follow his use of creative midfielders so closely.

Sam Kerr provides the domestic counterpoint. The Perth-born Matildas captain has spent years playing as a hybrid forward, dropping into the pocket to link play while remaining a clinical finisher, and the crowds that now follow the A-League Women across Australian venues have seen that profile become mainstream rather than exotic. The Socceroos' run at the 2015 Asian Cup in Melbourne, Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth, culminating in the final at Stadium Australia in Sydney, further confirmed that Australia can produce and appreciate football played in the modern mould.

Media conditions shape the conversation as much as tactics. A-League coverage has moved between Network 10, its sister channel and streaming platforms, jostling for Australian sports audiences against the AFL, the NRL and a summer cricket calendar that swallows the entire prime-time schedule. Footballers who cannot be sold on highlights struggle in that market, which favours the modern number 10, whose game travels well on a small screen.

The Socceroos have been in the unusual position of playing some of their best football in front of crowds that arrived expecting an AFL-style contest, and the disappointment was instructive. Australia has long borrowed the language of its rival codes, with a Brownlow Medal for the best player and footy tipping competitions that reward visibility. But the number 10 was never the most visible figure on an Australian field, and the modern game no longer asks him to be.

Soccer Unplugged has spent years arguing about football's history and its direction with exactly these characters in mind, from Lampard's late runs and Scholes' long passing to Gerrard's range and Shearer's finishing. Subscribe to the podcast, listen to the archive of episodes, and share the conversations that keep the debate moving. The number 10 is not dead; it has been rewritten, and the argument over who gets to wear its responsibilities will run for another generation.